Legal and Ethical Issues of Biometric Data and Aadhaar in India

Read Time:16 Minute, 3 Second

by Afifa Fatima, a B com LLB 3rd Year at Banasthali Vidyapith

Legal and Ethical Implications of Biometric Data Collection and Aadhaar Authentication

It has also noted that increasing trend of using the biometric for identification over the recent past years in India has legal and ethical implications. Some of the issues that have arisen regarding Aadhaar consist of the biometric database that was compiled during the process of creating Aadhaar through the various attributes like fingerprints and iris scans concerning Turn Constitution of the nation and the privacy and security of individuals. This article will therefore discuss the implications of biometric data collection and Aadhaar identification and review some of the matters and truths that revolve around it.

Privacy Concerns

Biometric data include finger prints and other scans like the iris scans are regarded as special category of personal data. There are also privacy concerns about the collection and storage of biometric data as such data is personal and anyone who gains access to such data may use it inappropriately. Measures to ensure the protection of data and methods of obtaining consent are a significant area that needs to be addressed to protect individuals’ personal data.

What can be said with a certain degree of certainty is that the controversy around biometric data collection and Aadhaar authentication is, in fact, framed with respect to privacy. Some of the areas that can be discussed with regards to security or protection of data that belong to certain individuals include the process of handling and storage of personal biometric data. This is due to the fact that the data can be manipulated, misused or accessed unauthorized, thus violating the privacy of individuals.

Also, linking it to various services and transactions through biometric data is a cause for concern over the monitoring of people’s activities, which infringes on their rights to privacy. This interconnectivity underlines that more existing and strengthened measures concerning adequate data protection and consent procedures safeguard privacy rights of a person.

Given that biometric data is unique and cannot be changed, some critical measures to ensure data security include encryption, access control, and auditing. In conclusion, biometric data collection requires the consent of the individuals involved in the process. Closely understanding of privacy policies and their explanations enable people manage their information exposures and improve the trust in the application of biometric technologies. Therefore, it is possible to address these concerns, and guarantee ethical collection and usage of biometric data by safeguarding the privacy of individuals and their rights over the biometric data.

Security Risks

The biometric data is also vulnerable to threats such as data leakage, identity theft, and third-party exploitation. Possible threats include alteration of biometric data and records, theft of such information, and use of the information by unauthorized individuals for unlawful activities. These risks can be managed by creating secure biometric databases and enforcing measures such as encryption and authentication to prevent misuse of biometric information.

Issues of security have become critical concerns in biometric data collection as well as Aadhaar authentication. One problem of the storing and transmitting of biometric information is the risks that can be easily targeted by an antagonist. Computer crime, scams, and other unlawful acts can ensue if the biometric database is accessed without the owner’s permission. However, controversies over the credibility of the infrastructure on which biometric data is collected and the Aadhaar authentication process have also been raised; these raise concern on the need to adopt appropriate security systems in guarding against situations like breach of data and cyber-attacks.

Biometric data is vulnerable to threats just like any personal information that is records; theft, piracy and other forms of unauthorized access. Concerns like those mentioned above are some of the risks that organizations face when using biometrics, and they can be overcome by ensuring security in the storage of biometric data, coupled with encryption and other forms of authentication to avoid misuse of biometric data.

Biometric data are as such invaluable and irreplaceable finger-print, iris/retina scan and other personal identification data, making them a likely target for the fraudster and identity thief. As we have seen, it is important to have strong measures in place to protect these biometric databases from any form of violation or incursion. Encryption involves techniques to encrypt the biometric data to help safeguard data both in storage and transmission, thus cannot be read if intercepted by unauthorized individuals.

Not only encryption is used but, identity verification in form of multi-factor and biometric authentication itself forms the layer of security to biometric systems. These help ensure that only the right people who have gone through some processes get to use the biometric data on an authorized manner.

Another important factor that can be put into the list of the company’s requirements for a reliable provider is the need to regularly conduct security audits and update security measures with reference to new threats and weak points that may appear in the process of the company’s activity. Through continually reviewing and implementing methods to address the threats, no compromise on the security of the biometric data, hence the protection of the individual’s information, can be achieved.

Constitutional Challenges

The increased use of biometric data, for instance, in identification including the Aadhaar authentication in India raised constitutional issues about privacy or individual’s data. Some of these concerns have been addressed by the Supreme Court of India in some of its historic judgments which directs that security concerns also as a paramount when it comes to privacy rights.

The constitutional questions add an extra layer to the legal and ethical questions regarding biometric data collection under Aadhaar. The enrolment and usage of Aadhaar has been an issue of debate with respect to the right to privacy, freedom, and personal liberty recognised under the Constitution. For this reason, the Aadhaar Act has been a point of the constitutionality of the Supreme Court of India that has made historical decisions that have shaped the law governing the deployment of biometric systems and their applicability to the identification of people.

Constitutional Challenges, the use of biometric solutions which are used for identification and verification like the Aadhaar system back in India has faced some constitutional issues over a certain right to privacy issues as well as data protection. While some of these issues have been partially answered by the Supreme Court of India in two case laws related to security and privacy principles, they are still vague and lack clarity.

Biometric data, especially fingerprints, is a privacy invasive method, Beyond that, concerns are that its use infringes on the right to privacy, which is enshrined in the Constitution of India. In More details, to resolve all these issues some of the prominent judgements were given by the Supreme Court of India such as Aadhaar case which was related to challenge to the constitutional validity of the Aadhaar scheme.

Speaking of its decisions, the Supreme Court noted that governments have to consider theories in security needs and rights to privacy. In tackling the question of biometric authentication as a means of enhancing the security in there and the efficiency of the service delivery, the Court has therefore underscored the need for protection of the rights to privacy as well as the right to personal liberty.

The Supreme Court’s judgments underscore the importance of upholding constitutional principles while harnessing the benefits of biometric technology for identity verification purposes.

Therefore, to some extent, addressing the concerns of the data Privacy as raised by the Supreme Court, the Aadhaar Act was amended to incorporate better mechanisms and conditions of data security and limitations of the use of Aadhaar data by the private parties.

The constitutional issues arising out of the collection and use of biometric data demonstrate that while national security may be an important consideration as well as an indivisible right, it does not automatically trump privacy and other liberties.

Data Protection Laws

India has passed the Personal Data Protection Bill that was framed for controlling the treatment of personal data including biometric particulars. Adhering to the provisions of data protection laws and regulations minimizes the risk of incorporating biometric data to facilities, systems and processes that collect, store and use personal data in a manner that is unlawful and opaque.

The Personal Data Protection Bill is an endeavour to formulate rules and regulation for the protection of individuals’ personal data and empowerment of persons with control over their own data and to regulate the processing of such data by any person [whether located in India or otherwise]. According to the bill, biometric data is defined as special category personal data and hence it is categorized as such since it cannot be easily replaced and is highly personal.

Compliance with data protection laws entails several key requirements, including:

Consent : Ensuring that individuals provide their clear and documented consent before being signed up for biometric collection and processing.
Purpose Limitation : Biometric data should be only used for purposes which it has been collected for excluding other unauthorized uses of the data.
Data Minimization : Biometric data which should be collected I accordance with other principles shall be collected for the prescribed and justified purpose and in a fair manner processed only to the extent necessary for the intended purpose.
Security Measures : Ensuring that proper measures and procedures that will prevent the leakage or random disclosure or misuse of the biometric data are in place.
Data Transfer : Ensuring that any transfer of biometric data made by an SPV or its service providers outside India shall also follow the provision of the data protection law and regulation of the country.

To sum up, it is crucial to point out the fact that by following these requirements, organisations will be able to foster people’s trust in organizations’ ability to keep people’s private data secure and to respect legal rules concerning biometric data processing. This assists in ensuring the people place their trust in such systems and affirm to using Biometric technology appropriately and with integrity.

Ethical Considerations

Consent and information disclosure, reporting, and impartiality are key ethical considerations that are intimately connected to the collection and utilization of biometric data. Some of the arguments raised assert that individuals should have own fundamental rights in relation to their biometric information and should be informed in advance about the utilization made of the data. This means that researchers should be willing to explain how they gathered data, and if the data was misused, then the researchers be punished.

1) Consent : The Biometric Data Processing Rules requires free consent of persons concerning the collection, processing, or use of somebody’s biometric data. This will ensure that people can have Self-Control over their personal information and can opt for it to be utilized.

2) Transparency : There have been worries on how biometric data is taken: Every organization that collects biometric data must display how it is collecting the biometric data, for what it is collecting the biometric data, how it intends to use the biometric data and whether the biometric data is disclosed to any other party. Using the principles of transparency, it is possible to explain why the disclosure of biometric identifiers is rational from the point of view of individuals and guarantees trust.

3) Accountability : The organizations that accept and process biometric data must assume some measure of responsibility for such information in terms of security and privacy. These include following the correct security measures, following the laws on protection of data and compensating persons affected as much as there is a violation as regards protection of personal data.

4) Fairness : Biometric systems should not be made to be very special or very complicated in such a way that some people can benefit at the expense of others and hence should be made fairly to all. On this note, there are fairness issues in terms of inherent bias in certain base algorithms as well as fairly unique biometric identity for every individual.

In this way, the organizations also provide how the Biometric data can be collected and used in a way that respects the rights of the individuals, is open to the public and accountable and earns the trust of the public in Biometrics..

Regulatory Oversight

Hence, this paper concludes that the legislative framework governing the collection and use of biometric data as well as the Aadhaar authentication system should be subject to reviews by the regulators with a view of socially auditing the proper implementation and compliance with the existing laws as a way of protecting the rights of the subjects and the prevention of misuse of collected biometric data. The following can be done to ensure that the abuse of a particular individual’s biometric data is prevented Some of the measures that may be taken so as to protect biometric data of a particular individual include:

Effective regulatory oversight involves several key functions:

Monitoring Compliance : There are several reasons why authorities regulate this process: to check the compliance of the subject organization with the legislation and requirements in the field of legal use of biometric data and their collection.
Enforcement Actions : Whenever non-compliance is observed, the regulatory authorities may exercise the legal measures that will ensure compliance from the non-compliant organization through fines, sanctions, or restraining orders that restrain the organization from violating the law in the future.
Investigations : Whenever there are complaints or new reports on alleged abuses on biometric data gathering and Aadhaar authentication, regulating authorities pursue cases and hearings to determine the credibility behind a complaint.
Guidance and Education : It unveiled the legal requirements that firms and people should follow in order to gain compliance and professional legitimacy for the biometric data collection and Aadhaar authentication.
Policy Development : Governmental agencies are incredibly helpful in aiding in the formulation of the policies, laws and guidelines concerning the biometric data gathering and usage; the regulatory structures adapt themselves to suit emerging technologies or in response to changes in the aspect of privacy.

By establishing and forming other distinct entities to monitor and oversee the use of the biometric information, the governments can increase the concern and guarantee that the level of accountability and transparency to help with the growth of public trust, as well as providing equality in the civil rights and privacy for all citizens.

The concerns and challenges described in this paper have called for the search for the appropriate measures to take that would equally safeguard the users’ rights to privacy while on the other hand ensuring that proper identity authentication is conducted. The protection of individuals’ biometric information as well as the utilisation of such information remains secure and ethical requires strict and strong legislation regimes on data protection laws and regulations. Binding consent norms, coupled with openness in the collection as well as usage of such biometric data, are prerequisite measures that can alleviate privacy issues and ensure adequate trust in the Aadhaar framework.

To address these concerns and challenges, it cannot be denied that the appropriate balance between the privacy risks as well as the necessity of accurate identity verification and authentication must be met. As articulated in this paper, sound legislative measures and policies are central to protecting individuals’ biometric details and promoting the proper and acceptable use of the technology.

Proper control over the collection and use of biometric data coupled with strict consent standards can go a long way in decreasing privacy violations fears and ensuring trust in the Aadhaar program. Biometric data should be collected, stored, and processed in a way that can be easily understood by the holders of this data and the use of which can be consented to or denied by the holder.

Additionally, enhanced ID verification tools like Aadhaar enable effective, efficient, and secure public service delivery. When the global governments and organizations use the biometric technologies for identity verification, such measures should respect people’s fundamental rights and freedoms while at the same time promoting the proper use of the technology and reducing the misuse of identity.

Indeed, a holistic approach that includes strong legal frameworks that protect persons’ biometric data, clear procedures on the use of biometric data, and sound identity verification processes can meet the issues and concerns that surround the collection of bio metric data and Aadhaar authentication while respecting individual rights and privacy.

From a security perspective, the use of secure cryptographic techniques, both for passwords and biometrics, routine assessments of the IT security and rigorous two-factor authentication is inevitable to strengthen the IT support structure for capturing biometrics and enabling Aadhaar authentication. Nevertheless, it is important to emphasize that security seems to be an overarching issue in biometrics since biometric information can be easily copied and misused, so ideas and measures aimed at making biometric systems safe from abuse and unauthorized access are critical to enhance security and protect the rights of people.

In order to preserve the privacy and security of the biometric data often used strong encryption is applied both at the time of transmission and storage so nobody can intercept or steal biometric data. Multi-factor authentication works in a way that requires the user to identify themselves in at least two different methods when accessing biometric identity or when seeking the services of an authentication service.

The standard security assessments are crucial for the recognition of various risks and risks in the framework of the technological structure connected with the gathering of biometric data and authentication of Aadhaar. Such audits are helpful to carry out at regular intervals so that one can detect the mishaps and bring them under control before they start posing a threat to the organizations’ systems.

In addition, measures to stop unauthorized access and abuses of the biometric data, including the use of control measures and authenticating mechanisms offer the necessary protection to the biometric records of the individuals. These measures restrict the availability of biometric data to only those employees who have a need to know and act on the data, thus reducing the risk of data leakage and misuse.

Therefore, there is a need for systematic security integrated with strict and effective encryption of the data, different levels of authentication, separate accounting, and qualitative measures against unauthorized access to the biometric database and the Aadhaar portal. Therefore, by focusing on this security matter, the organization is able to minimize this aspect of security so that the biometric information of individuals will not be a security menace. .

Conclusion

Therefore, complex legal and ethical concerns are associated with the biometric data collection and Aadhaar authentication system in India that ranges from privacy and security issues to constitutional and legal dilemmas. Dealing with these implications requires an integrated approach that addresses the need for better identity assurance and minimization of the negative impact to persons’ rights and security. Thus, thereby managing these challenges effectively, India can unlock the promise of biometric technology while respecting the rights and liberal values that define a democratic society.

Reference Material